- Research article
- Open Access
- Open Peer Review
One third of hospital costs for atherothrombotic disease are attributable to readmissions: a linked data analysis
BMC Health Services Researchvolume 14, Article number: 338 (2014)
Cardiovascular disease is the most frequent cause of death in Australia, with an associated cost burden of 11% of Australian annual health expenditure of which 40% is for hospital admissions. We investigated health outcomes and the components of hospital expenditure in the two years after an atherothrombotic disease admission to a tertiary hospital in an Australian setting.
Using data linkage we analysed two years of hospitalisation data and death records of all men and women aged 35–84 years with an admission to a Western Australian tertiary hospital for atherothrombotic disease in 2007. Costs were identified by matching the Australian refined diagnostic related group on the admission records to the published schedules of public and private hospital costs for the period of interest, and converted to 2013 Australian dollars.
Of 6172 patients studied (74% coronary, 20% cerebrovascular, 6% peripheral), 783 (13%) died during follow-up and 174 of these were in hospital case-fatalities at index. Thirty-two percent of patients (n = 1965) accounted for 3172 readmissions to hospital with one in three having multiple hospitalisations. The hazard ratio of atherothrombotic disease readmission was 1.45 (95% CI 1.27, 1.66) in those with more than one vascular territory affected compared to those with only one territory affected after controlling for age, sex, comorbidity, admission type, procedures, and episode length of stay. The total index plus 2-year admission cost for atherothrombotic disease was calculated at $101 million; $71 million for index, and $30 million for readmissions.
Among patients hospitalised with atherothrombotic disease, the cost of related rehospitalisations within 24 months is almost a third of the total. Much of the readmission costs fell within the first year. Whether readmissions and cost associated with atherothrombotic disease can be lowered through secondary prevention measures requires further investigation.
Cardiovascular disease (CVD) is the most frequent cause of death in Australia, and commands more of the government’s health expenditure than any other single disease. Approximately 11% of Australian annual health expenditure is spent on CVD, of which 40% is for hospital admissions . Based on the latest health expenditure report (2010–2011 financial year) this equates to $14 and $5.7 billion respectively . Better understanding of the hospitalisation costs associated with first and recurrent CVD events is central to evaluating the effectiveness of clinical care and planning for disease prevention.
The majority of CVD is attributable to atherothrombotic disease (ATD). ATD describes the shared pathology of atherosclerosis with superimposed thrombosis in ischaemic cerebrovascular disease (CeVD), coronary heart disease (CHD), and peripheral arterial disease (PAD); the combined determinants of CVD . Atherothrombotic events in the cerebral and coronary arteries are life threatening and those occurring in the peripheral arteries are predominately limb threatening. Such events require urgent hospitalisation and intervention to prevent death and/or loss of a limb. Furthermore, secondary prevention is a vital part of ATD management as those who have experienced one atherothrombotic event are at high absolute risk of further manifestations of the disease [4–6]. But it is well understood that not all those who could benefit from secondary prevention pharmacotherapy receive it . Work by Ademi et al. suggests that Western Australians are under-treated compared with the other Australian states . Furthermore, analysis of pharmacy data by Gunnell et al. suggests that a large proportion of Western Australian patients with coronary heart disease are not filling scripts for all recommended therapeutic types in 28 days .
The two year medical costs of ATD have been modelled for eight European countries,  and 12- and 18-month costs have been modelled in another two [11, 12]. However, the two year hospital costs and outcomes of a cohort of patients hospitalised with ATD has yet to be described in an Australian context, particularly in terms of time from discharge. Our objective is to determine the health outcomes and estimate hospital costs for ATD in the two years after admission to a tertiary hospital in an Australian setting.
The study sample comprised all Western Australian residents aged 35–84 years admitted to a tertiary public hospital in Perth during 2007 with a primary diagnosis of ATD selected using methods previously published . In Western Australia (WA) the tertiary hospitals provide patients with acute and elective arterial interventions such as coronary angiograms and invasive vascular procedures, these were not available at outer metropolitan and rural public hospitals until quite recently, and as such tertiary hospitals were the only public hospitals that provided these services in the study period. At discharge, a letter is sent to the patient’s general practitioner (GP), if they have one, and a copy is given to the patient. The hospital doctor also has the option of seeing the patient in an outpatient clinic some time after discharge, especially if the patient does not have a GP. These services are not captured by the linked administrative data and are not included in this analysis.
The first ATD admission to a tertiary hospital in 2007 was identified and considered the index admission (this could be incident or recurrent ATD). Major comorbidities for ATD were also identified . A history of ATD or comorbidity was recorded where so coded in any one of 21 diagnostic fields for any hospitalisation, including the index presentation, during the preceding 15 years . Cardiovascular cause of death was defined by ICD 10 - AM code from I00 to I99.
The data was extracted from two of the state’s administrative databases, the Hospital Morbidity Data Collection (HMDC) and Death Registrations. The HMDC covers all admissions to any public or private hospital in WA, while death registrations include those deaths registered in WA. Both databases are linked by the WA Data Linkage System at the Department of Health . Data linkage is performed using probabilistic matching with clerical review . The estimated proportion of invalid and missed links was 0.11% in 1996  and linkage quality is expected to remain at this level for links between hospital and death records.
An episode of care refers to the period from a person’s first admission to the hospital system until they leave the hospital system. This may be an admission and discharge from the same hospital, or a contiguous set of transfers among hospitals. Rehospitalisation or readmission refers to episodes of care occurring after the index event. Rehospitalisation and death data were available for two years after the index event.
Ethics approval was obtained from the Human Research Ethics Committees at the WA Department of Health and The University of Western Australia.
Costs were identified by matching the Australian refined diagnostic related group (AR-DRG) on the HMDC admission records to the published schedules of public and private hospital costs for the years from 2007 to 2009. We used AR-DRG version 5.1 public and private costs for admissions in 2007 and 2008, [17, 18] and the AR-DRG version 6.0 estimated public cost weights for admissions in 2009 . No private costs have been published for 2009. Costs were then converted to constant 2013 Australian dollars using health index deflators .
Individual level costs for ATD episodes of care (defined as an ATD code in the primary diagnosis field at least once during the episode) were calculated on the index admission, and summed for readmissions up to 24 months following the index admission.
Accessibility and remoteness and socio-economic disadvantage
The linked dataset included an Accessibility/Remoteness Index for Australia (ARIA+) and Socio-Economic Indices For Area (SEIFA) disadvantage score for each admission. ARIA + is based on distance by road to reach service centres . Residence at the time of hospitalisation was categorised as: major city, inner regional, outer regional, remote, or very remote. This was further grouped as metropolitan (major city) and rural (inner regional, outer regional, remote, and very remote). SEIFA disadvantage scores are an area level measure based on census data relating to income, education, unemployment and motor vehicle ownership . These scores are ranked and pooled into deciles, and were grouped into quintiles for this analysis. SEIFA disadvantage and ARIA + indices were missing for 270 (4%) patients.
Mean costs per individual for the index admission and for subsequent readmissions to 90 days, from 90 days to 12 months, and 12 to 24 months after index were calculated by 10-year age groups (35–44 years, 45–54 years, 55–64 years, 65–74 years, and 75–84 years at index admission), vascular territory, SEIFA disadvantage quintile, and ARIA + category of the index admission. Mean costs are presented as they reflect the population level costs. Chi-square test was used to compare the proportion of deaths in each age group.
Analysis of variance and t-tests were used to compare mean costs by age, sex, metropolitan or rural residence and socioeconomic disadvantage quintile. Cox regression was used to investigate factors associated with time to first ATD readmission within 2 years (and censored if died within 2 years). Age group, sex, rural or metropolitan residence, SEIFA disadvantage quintile, emergency or elective admission, vascular territory (incident or recurrent PAD, CeVD, or CHD), polyvascular disease (more than one territory affected), comorbidity history, and length of stay at the index admission were included in the base Cox model. Forward selection with significance level for entry set to 0.01 was used to check for interactions with age group, sex, polyvascular disease and index vascular territory. Statistical analysis was performed using SAS 9.4.
The sample comprised 6172 patients, the characteristics of which are presented in Table 1. Approximately two thirds were male, 79% were metropolitan residents and 21% in the most disadvantaged quintile. Coronary heart disease was the most common index diagnosis (n = 4571; 74%) and hypertension the most common comorbidity (n = 4009; 65%). Twenty-nine percent of patients had an ATD-related procedure at index, of these two-thirds had coronary stent procedures, 17% peripheral procedures, and 15% coronary artery bypass grafts.
There were 783 (13%) deaths in the two years (including those occurring at the index event) and of these 439 had a cardiovascular cause of death code. Most deaths occurred in the first twelve months after the index event (n = 557; 71%). Of these, 174 (2.8% of total studied) were in-hospital case-fatalities at the time of the index event and another 85 out-of-hospital fatalities occurred in the 28 days following their index admission. The oldest age group experienced the greatest proportion of deaths with much smaller proportions in the younger age groups (35–44 years, n = 15, 1.92%; 45–54 years, n = 56, 7.15%; 55–64 years, n = 95, 12.13%; 65–74 years, n = 190, 24.27%; and 75–84 years, n = 427, 54.53%; p < 0.0001).
Thirty-two percent (1965) of patients had at least one ATD readmission in the 2 years after the index admission and 1077 of those patients had a readmission in the first 90 days after the index admission. Fifty seven per cent of readmissions were emergency admissions. Table 2 shows the distribution of ATD readmissions and mean length of stay per admission by age group and overall.Figure 1 shows the pattern of readmissions over 2 years by type of index admission. Almost half of the patients with PAD were readmitted, mostly as elective cases. Whereas, a third of patients with CHD and one in seven with CeVD were readmitted and more so as emergency presentations. Readmissions involving another vascular territory were highest for stroke (39%), followed by PAD (20%) and CHD (7%). The proportions readmitted by index vascular territory was similar for each 10-year age group.
Factors associated with time to ATD readmission
Having ATD in more than one vascular territory at the index admission was highly significant, with the risk of ATD readmission approximately 1.5 times higher in those with polyvascular disease compared to those with only one vascular territory affected controlling for age, sex, comorbidity, admission type, procedures, and episode length of stay (HR 1.45; 95% CI 1.27, 1.66). Rural or metropolitan residence and SEIFA disadvantage quintile were not included in the final model as they were non-significant and missing values were restricting the study sample included in the analysis. The risk of readmission was 2.3 to 2.6 times higher for incident or recurrent PAD than incident CHD for emergency index admissions, but not for elective index admissions (Table 3). The risk of readmission was 1.3 times higher for recurrent CHD than incident CHD for emergency, but not elective. The risk of readmission was lower for incident and recurrent CeVD than incident CHD, but not statistically significant for elective recurrent CeVD.
In a Cox model with age group alone, the risk of readmission was lowest in the 35–44 years age group and all other age groups had similar risk (HR = 1.402 for 45–54 years, HR = 1.370 for 55–64 years, HR = 1.481 for 65–74 years, and HR = 1.460 for 75–84 years; all vs 35–44 years). However, in the fully adjusted model (polyvascular disease, index territory, sex, comorbidity, admission type, procedures, and episode length of stay), the risk of readmission tends to increase with age (HR = 1.290 for 45–54 years, HR = 1.265 for 55–64 years, HR = 1.348 for 65–74 years, and HR = 1.401 for 75–84 years; all vs 35–44 years).
The total index plus 2-year admission cost for ATD was calculated at $101 million; $71 million for index (6172 episodes of care), and $30 million for readmissions, comprising $14 million in the 90 days after the index admission, $9 million from 90 days to 12 months, and $7 million from 12 to 24 months. Hospital admission costs were highly skewed with many patients not contributing readmission costs and a few patients contributing very high costs.Figure 2 shows the mean ATD admission costs for men and women at each time point across five age groups. At index the mean cost of admission was not significantly higher for men ($11736, SD $14921) compared with women ($11039, SD $13846; p = 0.0673). However, readmission costs for ATD by sex at 90 days, 12 months were significantly higher for men, but not at 24 months follow-up (p < 0.0001; p = 0.0449; and p = 0.8586 respectively). There were no statistically significant differences in mean costs between age groups at each time point within males and females.
Index CeVD admissions had the highest mean cost ($18416, SD $19228), whilst patients with a PAD index admission had the highest mean readmission costs at 12 and 24 months (Table 4).
Emergency index admissions had the highest mean cost (Table 5). Of the readmission costs, the highest mean was for elective admissions within 90 days from index admission. Readmission costs decreased over time.
Rural residents, those in the inner and outer regional, remote and very remote ARIA + categories, had higher mean costs for the index tertiary hospital admission compared to major city residents ($13030 vs. $11088; p = 0.0001). Rural residents have a slightly longer, though not statistically significant, episode length of stay on the index admission. Readmission costs at each follow-up point were also slightly higher for rural residents, but the difference did not reach statistical significance.
The most disadvantaged socioeconomic quintile had the highest costs at index, 90 days, and 12 months (Table 6). At index and 24 months there were no statistically significant differences in mean costs between quintiles.
Of those admitted to a Perth tertiary hospital for ATD in 2007, 13% died and 32% experienced a readmission within 24 months. The 2-year cost to the health system, including index admission, was $101 million (2013 Australian dollars). Readmission costs for ATD in 24 months following an index admission were approximately 42% of the total, with more than three-quarters of these costs falling in the first 12 months after the index event.
A much greater proportion of those in the youngest age group had no readmissions, but there were remarkable similarities in the four older age groups and this cannot be explained by reduced follow-up in older age groups due to more deaths, as the estimated risks of readmission from the unadjusted Cox model showed a similar age pattern, reflecting the age-specific risks reported by Briffa et al. . In the fully adjusted Cox model however there appeared to be an increasing risk of readmission with increasing age.
Those with PAD experienced a high proportion of readmissions. Almost half of the PAD group experienced at least one readmission, and 80% of their readmissions were for PAD. PAD-related hospital admissions are usually for advanced disease requiring costly vascular procedures. Those with PAD are known to be prescribed fewer cardio-protective medications than their counterparts who have experienced CeVD or CHD . Improved use of secondary prevention drugs has the potential to reduce atherothrombotic change and delay or prevent hospital admissions for vascular procedures .
The international REACH registry reported that in three years of follow-up 28.4% of those with existing ATD experienced a vascular event or readmission after adjustment for age and sex, with those with CeVD experiencing the lowest readmission rates and PAD the highest . We observed a similar pattern of lower readmissions in CeVD and higher in PAD, but our study population experienced a greater proportion of readmissions. This is likely due to the selection of our study sample based on admission proximity, whereas the international REACH registry recruited from general practice. The Oxford Vascular Study did have an acute ATD event as the baseline but the outcome of interest included acute events only, with 16 per cent having at least one recurrent acute event . This population experienced a much higher proportion of CeVD (45%) and PAD (9%), and a lower proportion of CHD (42%). The large difference in CeVD may be attributed to the inclusion of those aged 85 years and older. The effects of polyvascular ATD and the index vascular territory on the risk of readmission for ATD are not unexpected. It likely reflects the use of vascular interventions and the complexity/severity of disease involving multiple territories.
The ATD hospital admission costs at 12 months for CHD, CeVD, and PAD are slightly higher than the mean hospital costs published by Ademi et al. in their analysis of the Australian REACH registry data in general practice patients . Only 12% of their study sample experienced a hospital admission in the one year of follow-up and almost 11% of REACH participants had no prior ATD hospitalisation, suggesting a more clinically stable population.
A European analysis by Levy and colleagues also indicated that the vast majority of costs are incurred in the first year, though the costs varied substantially between the different countries . The proportion of follow-up costs to acute costs for stroke in Europe ranged from 22% in Portugal to over 300% in France and Switzerland, though this included rehabilitation, which was not included in our study. For myocardial infarction it ranged between 33% in Portugal up to 114% in Austria.
The current study reports the costs associated with hospital readmissions for ATD in Perth Tertiary Hospitals. AR-DRGs have enabled measurement of the cost of ATD in such a large unselected sample. Indeed, a strength of the study is the bottom-up approach to costing by applying the individual AR-DRG costs to each admission in the dataset, based on the AR-DRG assigned in the HMDC. This means that the cost will best reflect the patient’s hospital admission and care costs. However, the costs assigned to AR-DRGs are based on an average patient across Australia and therefore may not reflect the precise costs incurred as a result of their admission.
In conclusion, among patients hospitalised with ATD the total 2-year cost to the health system at $101 million is substantial. The costs of ATD-related rehospitalisation within 90 days of the index admission are also sizable, across age and sex categories, and readmission costs within 24 months is 42% of the baseline admission costs. With 3172 readmissions, and well-known prevention treatment gap, there is a need to further investigate the cost-effectiveness of secondary prevention pharmacotherapy as a potential means for reducing readmissions and costs, in this setting.
Australian refined diagnostic related group
Accessibility/Remoteness Index for Australia
Coronary heart disease
Hospital Morbidity Data Collection
The International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health Problems, Tenth Revision
Peripheral arterial disease
Socio-economic Indices For Area
Australian Institute of Health and Welfare: Volume AIHW cat. no. CVD 53. Cardiovascular Disease: Australian Facts 2011 [Internet]. 2011, http://www.aihw.gov.au/publication-detail/?id=10737418510.
Australian Institute of Health and Welfare: Volume Cat. no. HWE 56. Health expenditure Australia 2010–11. 2012, Canberra: AIHW
Drouet L: Atherothrombosis as a systemic disease. Cerebrovasc Dis. 2002, 13 (suppl 1): 1-6.
Furie KL, Kasner SE, Adams RJ, Albers GW, Bush RL, Fagan SC, Halperin JL, Johnston SC, Katzan I, Kernan WN, Mitchell PH, Ovbiagele B, Palesch YY, Sacco RL, Schwamm LH, Wasserthiel-Smoller S, Turan TN, Wentworth D, on behalf of the American Heart Association Stroke Council, Council on Cardiovascular Nursing, Council on Clinical Cardiology, and Interdisciplinary Council on Quality of Care and Outcomes Research: Guidelines for the prevention of stroke in patients with stroke or transient ischemic attack. Stroke. 2011, 42 (1): 227-276.
Norman PE, Eikelboom JW, Hankey GJ: Peripheral arterial disease: prognostic significance and prevention of atherothrombotic complications. Med J Aust. 2004, 181 (3): 150-154.
Smith S, Allen J, Blair S, Bonow R, Brass L, Fonarow G, Grundy S, Hiratzka L, Jones D, Krumholz H, Mosca L, Pasternak RC, Pearson T, Pfeffer MA, Taubert KA: AHA/ACC guidelines for secondary prevention for patients with coronary and other atherosclerotic vascular disease: 2006 update. Circulation. 2006, 113 (19): 2363-2372.
Naderi SH, Bestwick JP, Wald DS: Adherence to drugs that prevent cardiovascular disease: meta-analysis on 376,162 patients. Am J Med. 2012, 125 (9): 882-887. e881
Ademi Z, Liew D, Chew D, Conner G, Shiel L, Nelson M, Soman A, Steg G, Bhatt DL, Reid C: Drug treatment and cost of cardiovascular disease in Australia. Cardiovasc Ther. 2009, 27 (3): 164-172.
Gunnell AS, Einarsdóttir K, Sanfilippo F, Liew D, Holman CDAJ, Briffa T: Improved long-term survival in patients on combination therapies following an incident acute myocardial infarction: a longitudinal population-based study. Heart. 2013, 99 (18): 1353-1358.
Levy E, Gabriel S, Dinet J: The comparative medical costs of atherothrombotic disease in European countries. Pharmacoeconomics. 2003, 21 (9): 651-659.
Maniadakis N, Kourlaba G, Cokkinos D, Angeli A, Kyriopoulos J: The economic burden of atherothrombosis in Greece: results from the THESIS study. Eur J Health Econ. 2013, 14 (4): 655-665.
Brüggenjürgen B, Rupprecht HJ, Willich SN, Spannagl M, Ehlken B, Smala A, Berger K, Diener HC: Cost of atherothrombotic diseases—myocardial infarction, ischaemic stroke and peripheral arterial occlusive disease—in Germany. J Public Health. 2005, 13 (4): 216-224.
Atkins E, Geelhoed E, Nedkoff L, Briffa T: Disparities in equity and access for hospitalised atherothrombotic disease. Aust Health Rev. 2013, 37 (4): 488-494.
Nedkoff L, Briffa TG, Knuiman M, Hung J, Norman PE, Hankey GJ, Thompson PL, Geelhoed E, Sanfilippo FM, Hickling S, Bremner A, Hobbs M: Temporal trends in the incidence and recurrence of hospitalised atherothrombotic disease in an Australian population, 2000–07: data linkage study. Heart. 2012, 98 (19): 1449-1456.
Data Linkage Western Australia [Internet]. [http://www.datalinkage-wa.org.au/]
Holman CDJ, Bass AJ, Rouse IL, Hobbs MST: Population-based linkage of health records in Western Australia: development of a health services research linked database. Aust N Z J Public Health. 1999, 23 (5): 453-459.
Public Sector Estimated Cost Weights Round 12 AR-DRG v5.1. [http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/Round_12-cost-reports]
Private Sector Estimated Cost Weights Round 12 AR-DRG v5.1. [http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/Round_12-cost-reports]
Public Sector - Estimated Round 14 (2009–10) AR-DRG 6.0x Cost Report. [http://www.health.gov.au/internet/main/publishing.nsf/Content/Round_13-cost-reports]
ARIA (Accessibility/Remoteness Index of Australia). [http://www.adelaide.edu.au/apmrc/research/projects/category/aria.html]
Australian Bureau of Statistics: Volume ABS cat. no. 2039.0. Information Paper: An Introduction to Socio-Economic Indexes for Areas (SEIFA), 2006. 2008, http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/mf/2039.0.
Briffa TG, Nedkoff LJ, Knuiman MW, Hankey GJ, Norman PE, Hung J, Thompson PL, Hickling S, Bremner A, Sanfilippo FM: Cross vascular risk for first and recurrent hospitalised atherothrombosis determined retrospectively from linked data. BMJ open. 2013, 3 (11): e003813-doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2013-0038135
Hankey GJ, Norman PE, Eikelboom JW: Medical treatment of peripheral arterial disease. JAMA. 2006, 295 (5): 547-553.
Steg P, Bhatt DL, Wilson PF, D’Agostino R, Ohman EM, Röther J, Liau CS, Hirsch AT, Mas JL, Ikeda Y, Pencina MJ, Goto S, for the REACH Registry Investigators: One-year cardiovascular event rates in outpatients with atherothrombosis. JAMA. 2007, 297 (11): 1197-1206.
Rothwell PM, Coull AJ, Silver LE, Fairhead JF, Giles MF, Lovelock CE, Redgrave JNE, Bull LM, Welch SJV, Cuthbertson FC, Binney LE, Gutnikov SA, Anslow P, Banning AP, Mant D, Mehta Z, for the Oxford Vascular Study: Population-based study of event-rate, incidence, case fatality, and mortality for all acute vascular events in all arterial territories (Oxford Vascular Study). Lancet. 2005, 366 (9499): 1773-1783.
Ademi Z, Liew D, Hollingsworth B, Wolfe R, Steg GP, Bhatt DL, Reid CM: The economic implications of treating atherothrombotic disease in Australia, from the government perspective. Clin Ther. 2010, 32 (1): 119-132.
The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6963/14/338/prepub
We acknowledge the Data Linkage Branch, the Inpatient Data Collection at the WA Department of Health and the WA Registry of Births, Deaths and Marriages for the provision of the data and linkages used in this study. The NHMRC funded the Real and Changing Atherothrombotic Disease Burden and Secondary Prevention project (#572558) but had no role in the design, analysis, writing or decision to publish this article.
The databases used are not freely available. The research project uses secondary (third party) data derived from Australian State government registries, which are ultimately governed by their ethics committees and data custodians. Therefore, any requests to share this data will be subject to formal approval from their ethics committees overseeing the use of these data sources, along with the data custodian(s) for the data of interest. Interested parties can apply to the relevant data custodians and ethics committees to request data, see http://www.datalinkage-wa.org/access-and-application
The authors declare there are no competing interests.
ERA, EAG, and TGB conceived of the study. MK provided expert advice and assistance in the selection and application of appropriate statistical analyses. ERA carried out the data analysis. All authors were involved in the interpretation of results and drafting of the manuscript. Each author has read and approved the submitted manuscript.