- Research article
- Open Access
- Open Peer Review
Primary care physician supply and other key determinants of health care utilisation: the case of Switzerland
© Busato and Künzi; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2008
- Received: 16 January 2007
- Accepted: 11 January 2008
- Published: 11 January 2008
The Swiss government decided to freeze new accreditations for physicians in private practice in Switzerland based on the assumption that demand-induced health care spending may be cut by limiting care offers. This legislation initiated an ongoing controversial public debate in Switzerland. The aim of this study is therefore the determination of socio-demographic and health system-related factors of per capita consultation rates with primary care physicians in the multicultural population of Switzerland.
The data were derived from the complete claims data of Swiss health insurers for 2004 and included 21.4 million consultations provided by 6564 Swiss primary care physicians on a fee-for-service basis. Socio-demographic data were obtained from the Swiss Federal Statistical Office. Utilisation-based health service areas were created and were used as observational units for statistical procedures. Multivariate and hierarchical models were applied to analyze the data.
Models within the study allowed the definition of 1018 primary care service areas with a median population of 3754 and an average per capita consultation rate of 2.95 per year. Statistical models yielded significant effects for various geographical, socio-demographic and cultural factors. The regional density of physicians in independent practice was also significantly associated with annual consultation rates and indicated an associated increase 0.10 for each additional primary care physician in a population of 10,000 inhabitants. Considerable differences across Swiss language regions were observed with reference to the supply of ambulatory health resources provided either by primary care physicians, specialists, or hospital-based ambulatory care.
The study documents a large small-area variation in utilisation and provision of health care resources in Switzerland. Effects of physician density appeared to be strongly related to Swiss language regions and may be rooted in the different cultural backgrounds of the served populations.
- Primary Care Physician
- Service Area
- Consultation Rate
- Language Region
- Swiss Health
Previous research on variations in the volume of physician services in geographic areas has emphasized that an additional use of services is not necessarily associated with improved health in the corresponding populations. After controlling for input prices and health status, it was found that the volume of physician services is driven partly by local practice patterns and partly by differences in physician density and speciality. However, an association between greater volume and demonstrable improvement in outcomes was not found .
Such findings may have contributed to a governmental decision to freeze new accreditations for physicians in private practice in Switzerland. This legislation is based on the assumption that demand-induced health care spending may be cut by limiting the associated care offers, a policy that initiated a controversial public debate in Switzerland. Therefore, the purpose of this article is to provide estimates of resource utilisation in Swiss primary care and to determine relevant factors in this context.
The Swiss health system is based on principles of free demand and supply and most services are reimbursed on a fee-for-service system. The system provides comprehensive coverage of high quality services, however, the financial costs rank second (after the US) among OECD countries and are still rising. Swiss health care is characterized by federalist structures and is fragmented into 26 cantonal health systems[4, 5]. National authorities have little responsibility and nationwide reforms aimed at cutting health care expenditures are therefore difficult to achieve.
Due to this highly decentralized governing of Swiss health care, the specific goals of the study include the estimation of spatial variability of availability and utilisation of primary care resources, taking into account demographic, socioeconomic, and cultural attributes of the population.
One of the problems associated with an estimation of the regional availability of health care is that patients frequently travel outside their residential areas to seek care, especially those residing in remote and non-urban areas. The formation of meaningful health service areas as a unit of analysis is thus an important issue as it allows the control of demand-induced utilisation phenomena, including medical consumerism. We have defined health care service areas for Swiss primary care based on the complete claims data of compulsory health insurance obtained from the data pool of all Swiss health insurers (santesuisse) and used these areas as the units of analysis. We therefore applied a new and alternative spatial model to describe the utilisation and provision of primary health care in Switzerland.
1018 ambulatory care service areas were created according to Goodman et al. based on 2761 communities and the community area codes of primary care physician practices and the residential addresses of their patients. For each service area, socio-demographic attributes were calculated using community data available from the Swiss Federal Statistical Office. The localisation index (LI) and the market share index (MSI) were calculated as measures of the health care utilisation and provision in each area. The LI indicates the degree of localization of primary care provided for the population in a given area and the MSI indicates the degree of localization of primary care provision from the provider's perspective .
Complete frequency data of all consultations reimbursed by the compulsory basic health insurance were obtained from the data pool of all Swiss health insurers (santésuisse) for all Swiss ambulatory care physicians for the year 2004. These data consisted of two files. The first file included a list of all Swiss ambulatory care providers classified into 49 different medical specialties with board certifications according to the Swiss Medical Association (FMH), together with the area codes of the practice locations. For this study, we used only consultations provided by primary care physicians (FMH board certifications for primary care, general internal medicine, general practitioner without board certification, incorporated group practice member). The second file included consultation frequencies of each physician classified by gender, by 20 age groups, and by community of patient residence. Patients' communities were therefore the smallest observational unit of this study. We used only data from consultations provided for illness and maternity. Accident-related consultations were excluded due to different health insurance coverage.
Descriptive analyses included the calculation of means and medians, depending on the distribution of the data. Univariate associations between variables were assessed with Spearman correlation coefficients (rho). Statistical models had to account for the two-level hierarchical structure of the data; i.e. level I data at the level of 2762 community levels and level II data at the level of 1018 service areas; consequently, multilevel models were used.
The main outcome variable of these models was the annual per capita consultation rate with a primary care physician for each community in the year 2004. Preliminary analyses indicated a symmetrical and almost normal distribution of this outcome variable. The following explanatory variables were analysed:
Level I (community attributes)
Average age of the population
Language code of the community (German, French, Italian, Romansh)
Proportion of non-Swiss citizens among the residents in each community
A nine level classification of communities: Urban, suburban, high income, peri-urban, tourist, industrial-tertiary, rural-commuter, agricultural-mixed, agricultural rural. This typology was developed by the Swiss Federal Statistical Office in order to provide a meaningful representation of communal characteristics for demographic and socioeocomic investigations . The classification is mainly based on the principle of hierarchic relationships between urban centres and peripheral communities.
Level II (service area attributes)
Area code of the service area (clustering variable)
Number of primary care physicians per 10'000 inhabitants (GP density)
Number of other, non-primary care physicians per 10'000 inhabitants (specialist density) in the same service area
Presence of a hospital providing ambulatory services in the same service area (coded as a binary variable with 0 for no hospital and 1 for at least one hospital).
Additional language-stratified analyses were performed because of significant language-related first-order interaction terms. Since there are only a few communities in which Romansh is spoken, stratified analyses were restricted to German-, French-, and Italian-speaking communities only. The stratified models comprised the same set of explanatory variables except language region and the related interaction terms. Presence of hospital, language region, and community type were treated as classification variables, and continuous explanatory variables were centred to facilitate parameter interpretation. Results for classified data were interpreted as least-square means (LS-Means) with 95% confidence intervals (CI95), and the Bonferroni procedure was used to adjust for multiple comparisons. Variance components of level II variables were additionally calculated. Variance components quantify the corresponding proportions of outcome variation accounted for by specific variables and therefore provide estimates about the relevance of regional variables within Swiss primary care. Model fit was assessed using residual analyses and the Akaike Information Criterion (AIC) was used to compare several versions of the model during model development. Residual analysis showed no violation of basic assumption for linear models. SAS 9.1 (SAS Institute Inc., Cary, NC, USA) and "proc mixed" were used for all analyses and the level of significance was set at 0.05 throughout the study.
Distribution of physicians and consultation frequencies across community types (2760 communities)
Type of communitya
Number/proportion of physicians
Physicians per 10,000 inhabitants
Proportion of consultations
Per capita consultation rate
Attributes of 1018 primary care service areas
No. of communities
No. of physicians
Consultations per inhabitant
Market share index
Parameter estimates of continuous explanatory variables for annual per capita consultation rates with primary care physicians
Nonstratified, full model
Estimates of language-stratified models
Number of GP's/10'000 inhabitants
Number of specialists/10'000 inhabitants
-0.02 – -0.004
Female to male ratio
Interaction (Female to male ratio * Non-Swiss citizens)
Least square means (LSM) of annual per capita consultation rates with primary care physicians across language regions, community types, and hospital regions
95% confidence limits
Pair-wise comparisons of means indicated multiple significant differences between language regions. Only the consultation frequencies for German and Italian vs. Romansh were not significantly different. Least square means indicated furthermore that agricultural/rural and high-income communities had the lowest and industrial/tertiary communities had the highest frequencies (Table 4). All other community types were closely scattered around the overall Swiss mean of a 2.95 per capita consultation rate with a primary care provider.
Significant first-order interaction terms indicated that the effects of GP density and the proportion of non-Swiss citizens were not constant across language regions. Therefore, additional specific analyses stratified by language (Tables 3 and 4) were performed. These data indicated that language-specific effect estimates of the association between GP density and consultation rates were lower than the overall Swiss estimate. GP consultation rates increase significantly by 0.06 for each additional GP in a population of 10'000 inhabitants in the Swiss German-speaking population, whereas considerably lower and non-significant effects were observed in French- and Italian-speaking regions (Table 3). Inverse patterns were seen for the association between the GP-consultation rate and the regional density of specialists. Specialists had a negative effect on GP-consultation rates in all regions. However, this effect was seen only in German-speaking regions significantly associated with GP-consultations (Table 3).
The proportion of non-Swiss citizens appeared, in terms of effect size, to be the most important factor among continuous variables at the community-level for the Swiss German population (Table 3). This implies that GP-consultation rates increased significantly with higher proportions of non-Swiss citizens by a factor of 2.08 for each additional percent of non-Swiss citizens in a community. Less prominent and non-significant effects were seen for this factor in other Swiss language regions.
Variance components of regional variables
Proportion of regional variation
No. of GP's/10'000 inhabitants
No. of specialists/10'000 inhabitants
There are several theoretical models in health systems research that are used to explain the availability and utilisation of health related resources [12–14]. Most of these models distinguish between supply- and demand-related factors, and this conceptual differentation was adapted, therefore, for the following discussion.
Regulation of physician's supply
Swiss health care is characterised by a high degree of decentralisation with strong regional and cantonal influence and high cost . Coordinated and effective interventions to maintain and improve cost-efficiency are thus difficult to achieve. However, as an extraordinary measure, federal legislation in the year 2000 gave the 26 cantonal authorities the authority to restrict the number of ambulatory health care providers. This decision was based mainly on an economic rationale regarding the supply hypotheses of practice variation and should have resulted in a more or less complete stop of new accreditations of Swiss primary care providers in the following years. Apparently, these governmental measures provoked just the opposite effect as the number of newly accredited physicians increased ! The association between physician density and the intensity of utilisation of health care resources thus remains a relevant factor in the current debate about reducing costs in Swiss health care. In contrast to previous analyses based on cantonal data, we propose the use of health service areas as the unit of analysis of potential determinants of health care utilisation. This approach reduces the effect of patients seeking care outside their residential area. As this paper demonstrates, without this bias a much better representation of the actual utilization and provision of resources in Swiss primary care can be achieved.
Determinants of utilization of primary care resources
The analysis of per capita consultation rates across language regions confirms well known cultural differences in Switzerland that extend beyond health care ; but the differences we observed between the French and other language regions were larger than expected. Other research in Switzerland showed that these differences are neither related to variations in health status nor to socioeconomic attributes of the respective populations and, furthermore, the same research also indicated a lack of theoretical specification and empirical models in this context . We therefore can only assume that patients in French-speaking communities directly seek care more often from specialists without first consulting a primary care provider. Similar mechanisms may also be at least partially responsible for the observed disparities between the different community types. However, traditionally anchored behavioural patterns and effects of the political and institutional environment including different accessibility of resources can additionally influence the consultation pattern of the underlying populations.
Additional research aimed at these topics is thus needed to investigate the distribution of population-based consultation patterns across language regions, community types, medical specialties, and the corresponding implications on cost for ambulatory care. Presently, we also see strong political pressure to implement managed care, e.g., by establishing physician networks based on gate-keeping. Our results may therefore help guide future developments by setting population-based and regional priorities.
The data provide estimates of the importance of socio-demographic factors relevant for the utilisation of primary care resources in Switzerland. Effects of age and gender confirm well known phenomena in this context. However, particularly in the Swiss German population, the effect of non-Swiss residents far exceeds corresponding effects of other socio-demographic and supply-related factors. These results thus confirm other research in this field, showing a heterogeneity of emigrants across Swiss language regions in terms of gender, ethnical background, migration history and legal status of residency [19, 20]. Possible explanations of these findings may be provided within the conceptual framework of cultural epidemiology where health and illness are understood as socio-cultural categories that influence the perception of well being . The findings support, however, ongoing efforts facilitating information, prevention and health care for migrants and improving the cultural competence of care providers . In addition, the findings may also be relevant to many other health care systems facing worldwide refugee and migration phenomena.
Our data provide evidence that the number of physicians accredited in a specific region is an important determinant for the utilisation of Swiss primary care resources. However, the associated effects are not consistent across Swiss language regions and show an inverse relationship between primary care providers and specialist care. The findings not only imply considerable competition for patients between specialists and primary care physicians in the Swiss German regions, but also indicate that the utilisation of primary care resources in these regions is obviously more supplier-driven than in other regions. In contrast, effects of hospital-based supply of ambulatory services remain constant across language regions and indicate consistent patterns of competition: the presence of ambulatory hospitals reduces GP consultations by 0.18 per year and inhabitant.
The question remains, therefore, what are the major driving forces for these findings? Is it supplier-induced demand, clinical uncertainty, or patient needs; and what are the roles of the 'zero risk society' or of medical consumerism?  The length of the observation interval may exclude simple fluctuating levels. It may be argued that the available data provide no insight into the decision-making process of individuals seeking and providing care, and consequently that the data do not permit a distinction between demand manipulation and clinical ambiguity . However, our data cover the entire range of non-accident-related primary care reimbursed by social health insurance, including non-clinical incentives and competition factors. These factors together may influence professional activities of physicians working on a fee-for-service basis. Nevertheless, supply-induced demand cannot be excluded as an explanation of our findings, particularly in Swiss German regions. However, variance component analysis reflected not only the decentralized structure of Swiss health care but also provided an estimate of the potential importance of regulatory interventions. From a national perspective, supply-related components contribute only marginally to regional variation in the use of primary care resources. Therefore, the impact of a regulation of supply by, for example, freezing the number of primary care physicians may have only a very limited or even immeasurable effect on the associated resource utilisation. However, language-stratified analyses indicated that considerable amounts of variance are accounted for by the GP-density in Swiss German regions, and specialist and hospital supply in French-speaking regions.
Limitations and strengths
The results were derived from the claims database of all Swiss health insurers and provide complete coverage of all ambulatory or outpatient services reimbursed by compulsory Swiss social health insurance in 2004. The spatial model used in this study yielded service areas in which, on average, 57% of the population used local health resources, and/or physicians treated local patients in 61% of all consultations. We therefore consider this approach an appropriate spatial representation of utilisation and provision of primary care in Switzerland. It can be debated, however, whether a proportion of 36.4% of explained variance of the outcome is enough to draw relevant conclusions about the effect of physician density and socioeconomic determinants on per capita consultation rates. Our model was based on a set of only nine explanatory variables and on an outcome with known high random error. We consider it unlikely, given the type and extent of data available, that the results are biased due to measurement error. Furthermore, the explanatory variables were derived from aggregated data at the community and service area levels, and not from individuals – the interpretation of the results is thus limited to these two distinct levels of aggregation and cannot be extended for individual patients or physicians. Given these factors, we believe the achieved amount of explained variance merits publication of the data. Furthermore, the distinct multi-cultural population mix in Switzerland offers excellent conditions for studying health care use across different cultures. A potentially significant imitation in interpreting our data on resource use and volume in Swiss primary care is related to the fact that the referral data are still incomplete. A further limitation derives from the fact that the activity levels of the physicians were not accounted for in the analysis, i.e., full-time and part-time physicians were equally weighted. Other limitations attach to the cross-sectional nature of the study, since service areas are not stable constructs over time because the availability and utilisation of resources may change rapidly. The methods applied in this work are not perfect, but they may be helpful in describing, understanding, and managing the underlying processes.
Our study confirms other reports documenting large small-area variations in the utilisation and provision of health care resources in the multicultural population of Switzerland [15, 23]. In contrast to other research, we propose an alternative spatial model for analysing resource utilisation in order to provide comparable, utilisation-based service areas. We quantified the effects of health system factors, including physician density, as key elements of per capita consultation rates in Swiss primary care. Physician density appeared to be a relevant factor associated with resource utilisation. The effects of primary care providers and specialists were, however, different across language regions, and hence, cultural background. Only limiting the number of care providers may not bring significant changes in volume. Therefore, additional measures to reduce unexplained variation in volume, such as providing physicians with data on their resource use compared with clinical reasoning based on evidence-based guidelines and the practice patterns of their peers, may be evaluated further. Early experiments using educational forms of feedback proved successful in changing physician behaviour and the associated costs in the long run [24, 25].
The study was funded by the Swiss Health Observatory and, by contractural agreement, the funding organization had no involvement in the preparation of the present manuscript.
We acknowledge the work of Dr. H. Jaccard and M. Roth of the Swiss Health Observatory and M. Bertschi of santesuisse for their help and support in the project, and we thank Chris Ritter for his help preparing the manuscript.
- Wennberg JE, Fisher ES, Skinner JS: Geography and the debate over medicare reform. Health Aff (Millwood). 2004, W96-114. Suppl Web ExclusiveGoogle Scholar
- Fisher ES, Wennberg DE, Stukel TA, Gottlieb DJ, Lucas FL, Pinder EL: The implications of regional variations in Medicare spending. Part 2: health outcomes and satisfaction with care. Ann Intern Med. 2003, 138 (4): 288-298.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- 832.103 S: The Swiss Federal Council: Verordnung über die Einschränkung der Zulassung von Leistungserbringern zur Tätigkeit zu Lasten der obligatorischen Krankenpflegeversicherung. 2002Google Scholar
- OECD/WHO: OECD and WHO survey of Switzerland's health system. 2006, Organisation for Economic Co-operation and DevelopmentGoogle Scholar
- Herzlinger RE, Parsa-Parsi R: Consumer-driven health care: lessons from Switzerland. Jama. 2004, 292 (10): 1213-1220. 10.1001/jama.292.10.1213.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Goodman DC, Mick SS, Bott D, Stukel T, Chang CH, Marth N, Poage J, Carretta HJ: Primary care service areas: a new tool for the evaluation of primary care services. Health Serv Res. 2003, 38 (1 Pt 1): 287-309. 10.1111/1475-6773.00116.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Klauss G, Staub L, Widmer M, Busato A: Hospital service areas – a new tool for health care planning in Switzerland. BMC Health Serv Res. 2005, 5 (1): 33-10.1186/1472-6963-5-33.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Singer J, Willett JB: Applied longitudinal analysis. 2003, New York: Oxford University PressView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Schuler M, Dessermontet P, D J: 2005, Die Raumgliederungen der Schweiz: Swiss Federal Statistical OfficeGoogle Scholar
- Singer J: Using SAS PROC MIXED to fit multilevel models, hierarchical models, and individual growth models. Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics. 1998, 24 (4): 323-355. 10.2307/1165280.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Wennberg J, Gittelsohn : Small area variations in health care delivery. Science. 1973, 182 (117): 1102-1108. 10.1126/science.182.4117.1102.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Andersen RM: Revisiting the behavioral model and access to medical care: does it matter?. J Health Soc Behav. 1995, 36 (1): 1-10. 10.2307/2137284.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Grossman M: 2000, The Human Capital Model of the Demand for Health: NewhouseGoogle Scholar
- McGuire T: Handbook of Health Economics Physcian Agency, Chapt 9. 2000, Elsevier Science B.V, 1.Google Scholar
- Crivelli L, Filippini M, Mosca I: Federalism and regional health care expenditures: an empirical analysis for the Swiss cantons. Health Econ. 2006, 15 (5): 535-541. 10.1002/hec.1072.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Marty F: Praxiseröffnungsinserate in der Schweizerischen Ärztezeitung von Mitte 1997 bis Ende 2004. Teil 1. Primary Care. 2005, 5: 455-458.Google Scholar
- Vatter A, Rüefli C: Do political factors matter for health care expenditures? A comparative study of Swiss cantons. Jnl Publ Pol. 2003, 23 (3): 301-323. 10.1017/S0143814X03003143.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Bisig B, Gutzwiler F: Gesundheitswesen Schweiz: Gibt es Unter-oder Überversorgung? Band 1: Gesamtübersicht. 2004, Verlag Ruegger Zürich/Chur, 2.Google Scholar
- FOPH: Forschung Migration und Gesundheit. 2006, Swiss Federal Office of Public HealthGoogle Scholar
- Gilgen D, Maeusezahl D, Salis Gross C, Battegay E, Flubacher P, Tanner M, Weiss MG, Hatz C: Impact of migration on illness experience and help-seeking strategies of patients from Turkey and Bosnia in primary health care in Basel. Health Place. 2005, 11 (3): 261-273. 10.1016/j.healthplace.2004.04.002.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Fugelli P: The Zero-vision: potential side effects of communicating health perfection and zero risk. Patient Educ Couns. 2006, 60 (3): 267-271. 10.1016/j.pec.2005.11.002.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Davis P, Gribben B, Scott A, Lay-Yee R: The "supply hypothesis" and medical practice variation in primary care: testing economic and clinical models of inter-practitioner variation. Soc Sci Med. 2000, 50 (3): 407-418. 10.1016/S0277-9536(99)00299-3.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Nocera S, Wanzenried G: On the Dynamics of Physician Density; Theory and Empirical Evidence for Switzerland. Research Papers in Economics. 2002, [http://ideas.repec.org/p/ube/dpvwib/dp0208.html]Google Scholar
- Winkens RA, Pop P, Grol RP, Kester AD, Knottnerus JA: Effect of feedback on test ordering behaviour of general practitioners. Bmj. 1992, 304 (6834): 1093-1096.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Bradley C: Provision of cost information changes physician behaviour and reduces costs. Evidence-Based Medicine. 1998, 3 (2): 62.Google Scholar
- The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1472-6963/8/8/prepub
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.