You are viewing the site in preview mode

Skip to main content

Advertisement

Table 6 Summary of completed PRISMA checklist for all included reviews

From: Integration of care for hypertension and diabetes: a scoping review assessing the evidence from systematic reviews and evaluating reporting

PRISMA checklist item Atlantis 2014 [23] Huang 2013 [24] Joshi 2014 [25] Smith 2016 [26] Watson 2013 [27]
Title
 1. Title Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Abstract
 2. Structured summary Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Introduction
 3. Rationale Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
 4. Objectives Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Methods
 5. Protocol and registration No Yes Yes Yes Yes
 6. Eligibility criteria Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
 7. Information sources Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
 8. Search Yes Yes No Yes Unclear
 9. Study selection Yes Yes No Yes Yes
 10. Data collection process Partly Partly No Yes Yes
 11. Data items No Yes No Yes Yes
 12. Risk of bias in individual studies Partly Yes No Yes Yes
 13. Summary measures Yes Yes N/A Yes Yes
 14. Synthesis of results Yes Yes No Yes Yes
 15. Risk of bias across studies Yes Yes No Yes Unclear
 16. Additional analyses Partly Yes No Yes Yes
Results
 17. Study selection Yes Yes Not adequate Yes Yes
 18. Study characteristics Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
 19. Risk of bias within studies Partly Yes No Yes Unclear
 20. Results of individual studies Yes Yes No Yes Yes
 21. Synthesis of results Yes Yes N/A Yes Partly
 22. Risk of bias across studies No N/A No Yes No
 23. Additional analysis Yes N/A N/A N/A No
Discussion
 24. Summary of evidence Yes Yes Yes Yes Partly
 25. Limitations Partly Yes Partly Yes Yes
 26. Conclusions Yes Partly Partly Yes Yes
Funding
 27. Funding Yes No Yes Yes Partly
Number of items included (yes) 19/27 22/27 10/27 26/27 19/27